_______________________________
                                                   |                               
                           _Valentine Gill HALL Sr_|
                          |                        |
                          |                        |_______________________________
                          |                                                        
 _Valentine Gill HALL Jr__|
| (1834 - 1880)           |
|                         |                         _______________________________
|                         |                        |                               
|                         |_Susan TONNELÉ ________|
|                                                  |
|                                                  |_______________________________
|                                                                                  
|
|--Mary Livingston HALL 
|  (1869 - 1872)
|                                                   _______________________________
|                                                  |                               
|                          _Edward Hunter LUDLOW __|
|                         | (1810 - 1884) m 1833   |
|                         |                        |_______________________________
|                         |                                                        
|_Mary Livingston LUDLOW _|
  (1843 - 1919)           |
                          |                         _Edward Philip LIVINGSTON _____+
                          |                        | (1779 - 1843)                 
                          |_Elizabeth LIVINGSTON __|
                            (1813 - 1896) m 1833   |
                                                   |_Elizabeth Stevens LIVINGSTON _+
                                                     (1780 - 1829)